Critical Response and Legacy
By the mid-1840s, Simms's fame for his novels was so great that Edgar Allan Poe declared Simms to be "The best novelist which this country has, on the whole, produced" and "immeasurably the greatest writer of fiction in America". Simms's story collection The Wigwam and the Cabin was singled out by Poe as "decidedly the most American of American books". However, despite having achieved a very good literary reputation during his lifetime, today Simms' novels are, for the most part, out of print. Eminent Simms scholar Dr. David Aiken has observed that Simms was purged from the canon of American literature because of the "unpardonable sin Simms committed when he published an account of Columbia's destruction in which he dared to deny the North a righteous victory" as Simms asserted of the North's tactics in the Civil War, "whatever might have existed in virtue of their cause, is forfeit by the processes which they have taken for its maintainance". Donald Davidson claimed, "The neglect of Simms' stature is nothing less than a scandal when it results....in the disappearance of his books from the common market and therefore from the readers' bookshelf. This is literary murder". Still, he is known among literary scholars as a major force in Antebellum literature., and though his outstanding genius and literary accomplishments have been largely overlooked, this has caused Simms to come to embody the "outsider" nature of contemporary Southern fiction.
Dr. Mary Ann Wimsatt, the major Simms scholar of her generation, has published dozens of articles and two widely praised books about the author. The first book, The Major Fiction of William Gilmore Simms, was published by Louisiana State University Press in 1989. The second, an edition of twelve Simms short stories titled Tales of the South, was published by the University of South Carolina Press in 1996. A reviewer in The Virginia Quarterly Review styled Wimsatt's edition magisterial.
A large bust of Simms is centrally located in Charleston's Battery Park.
Read more about this topic: William Gilmore Simms
Famous quotes containing the words critical, response and/or legacy:
“Good critical writing is measured by the perception and evaluation of the subject; bad critical writing by the necessity of maintaining the professional standing of the critic.”
—Raymond Chandler (1888–1959)
“Perhaps nothing in all my business has helped me more than faith in my fellow man. From the very first I felt confident that I could trust the great, friendly public. So I told it quite simply what I thought, what I felt, what I was trying to do. And the response was quick, sure, and immediate.”
—Alice Foote MacDougall (1867–1945)
“What is popularly called fame is nothing but an empty name and a legacy from paganism.”
—Desiderius Erasmus (c. 1466–1536)